I love you much. [but] it’s not enough that you love blow and I love puff.
Amy Winehouse
Back to Black
I have dear friends with appalling politics. As you might expect, they would tell you the same thing. Lately, though, we’re wondering why, after many years of evenings spent in spirited political discourse, we now seem unable to keep civil tongues in our heads when we’re discussing politics.
Like Winehouse’s song of a relationship that revolves around a woman’s love of crack cocaine, and her man’s love of traditional cocaine, our political discussions are no longer strengthening and enriching our understanding of one another–they are just casting a pall over it.
To these friends, my views are predictably liberal. To me, their views are built merely to defend their conservative ideology.
Ideology is the insidious drug that we’re sharing.
So, friends, let’s move to a higher level of political discourse. And in this new place, to paraphrase Shakespeare’s Henry VI, first let’s kill all the idealogues.
In our discussions, let’s agree to stop saying things like:
… that’s typical liberal claptrap.
… conservatives always say that.
… conservatives reduce everything to money.
… liberals just want big government.
Just as we instructed our children on the playground, let’s make it a rule that we are not allowed to use labels against each other. Even if you really believe any of those statements, let’s refuse to employ them in the understanding that they do nothing to persuade or advance your argument.
Let’s replace the heated exchanges of accusations, with exchanges of questions.
“What informs your opinion?”
“Do you not think X is true?”
“Do you not think X is important?”
Instead of hurling “facts” at one another in order to knock down ideological walls, let’s step outside those walls and try to shed light on our disagreements.
Now, if any of my friends were in the camp that believes liberalism is, in and of itself, wrong, we would have nothing to discuss.
Luckily, all of my friends are smarter than that.
* * * * * * *
When it comes to defending ideological walls, Alaskan Gov. Sarah Palin seems to be a near Joan of Arc.
My conservative friends are so enthralled with her–and, hey, I’m impressed by her, too!–that I hate to pour water on their enthusiasm.
So, instead, I’ll direct them to the well-chosen words of former Easton Express editor Chris Satullo.